Tag banned at many schools
Published on May 14, 2007 By Texas Wahine In Blogging
I can hardly believe this.

I just got a voice mail from my child's school's vice principal (I have a home phone, but for some reason he felt the need to call me on my cell, which does not always get reception in my house). He called to inform me that my child had been in the office, speaking to both the principal and vice principal about his inappropriate behavior on the playground at recess.

The vp went on to say that my child was in trouble for slapping other students (ok, that's bad). Then the vp adds, "Or as he calls it, playing tag."

OMG.

My child did not just get sent to the office to be scolded and psychoanalyzed by two different administrators for PLAYING TAG.

The note that was sent home calls his crime "physical contact/inappropriate behavior". Apparently the school is a "no tag zone". When I was in first grade I chased a boy, knocked him down, and kissed him. Wonder if that would be considered "physical contact/sexual assault"?

The vp implored me to talk to my child and support the school in this matter.

I support the school in that whatever the rules are, my child must obey them. But I'm not going to punish my child for playing tag. It's what kids do. They chase each other around and play tag. It's not slapping. It's a game played by children around the world. It has dozens of variations and goes by dozens of different names.

It's La Anda in Costa Rica, Fangen in Germany, Kucing-Kucingan in Indonesia, Hippa in Finland, Berek in Poland, and Pega Pega in Brazil. You can play it in the dark and call it Kabuki. You can wear a blindfold and call it Marco Polo. You can join hands and call it Blob Tag. You can stand still and call it Freeze Tag.

Tag is as fundamental as children's games get. It's at the core of almost every active game a child could possibly play.

So, I did indeed talk to my son, and he knew he was not allowed to play tag. He saw some other children playing it in front of a teacher without the teacher intervening so he and some other children decided tag was back on the menu. He tagged another child in the course of the game, and he (and he alone) was sent to the office.

I am surprised that they've made this big a deal out of a game of tag.

I'm all for safety, but I think this is more than just a little bit silly. I'm not going to ground my child or make him write an essay for playing tag with a bunch of other kids and have the misfortune of being the one singled out for it. I'm not one of those moms who believes my child never does anything wrong. I live with him; I know better. I do think he's getting crapped on in this situation, though.

I reminded him that the rules always apply to him no matter what, and that was that.

It's frickin' tag. It's not inappropriate behavior.
Comments
on May 14, 2007
That really sucks that your son got singled out from all the others. Maybe the other kids have created some kind of "no tag" tag technique? It's so weird.

Sometimes I wonder if schools do this because of the hot-house flower attitude some people have towards raising their children. That plus litigation. Kids get bumps and bruises and it's a big part of being a kid. I think it's a big part of toughening up and not being wimpy. If I got hurt and I didn't need immediate hospitalization, my dad usually just told me to go back and play. Okay, I exaggerate a bit. I would get a band-aid or a cut washed out and when I was under 6 he used to draw a picture of a bunny on my ouchie with mecurachrome (spelling?), then I was told to go play.

I hate it when I'm teaching and the kids play tag. I'm always praying that some kid doesn't have a clumsy moment and trip over his feet, or have an up-close and very personal physics lesson and find out what happens when a slower or stationary object is hit by a faster moving object. I can monitor the kids and make sure that no one is using tag for bullying but I can't prevent clumsiness or accidents. I've been lucky, but I know that some parents have a hard time accepting their kid got a knock by doing things that kids do. And then one reads the newspaper and finds litigation about the stupidest things that just used to be about being a kid.

But I love tag. I still love tag. I just don't want to be involved in any way when I'm responsible for other people's kids. Especially if I don't really know the parents. It annoys me that I feel that way. I feel like I contribute to developing hot-house flowers. But it's not my child so I can't decide in that matter. I guess err on the side of safety. But it feels like it's taking away from the childhood experience.
on May 14, 2007
momijiki: I can understand tag would make a teacher uncomfortable. It just seems insane to me that kids can't even play this most basic of games.

Maybe we should send our kids to school wrapped in bubble wrap so they won't get hurt (and no one will get sued).

I'm also more than a little annoyed at the big deal that was made out of it. A verbal reprimand could have been issued on the spot ("No playing tag. Find something else to play, please.")

I actually don't mind if my kids are sent to the office if they've done something to warrant it. I'm just a little shocked the school felt a game of TAG warranted a double dose of authority in the office. Ugh.
on May 14, 2007
Thank GOD I went to school when I did and not these days.
on May 14, 2007

The more I read about Public School, the more I believe that educators have completely lost their minds.

I am glad you took the time to find out if your son knew Tag was agaisnt the rules though.  You are right, if he knew he was breaking a rule, he needs to be reprimanded for it... but the reprimand needs to be reasonable considering the "offense".

If that were my kid, I would have had him wait outside the office while I talked to the principal.  I would then tell the principal that he or she is guilty of  "pscyo contact/unbelievable behavior".  I would question his or her intelligence, along with anyone else's who made such a demeaning and outrageous rule.  I would then go on to inform the educated idiot that no school should be inflicted with administrators or faculty who lack the ability to think.

Of course, I wouldn't say any of that in front of my kid, that would be as unprofessional and illadvised as the school is being.

 

on May 15, 2007
Maybe we should send our kids to school wrapped in bubble wrap so they won't get hurt (and no one will get sued).


Sad reflection on society, no?

I'm also more than a little annoyed at the big deal that was made out of it. A verbal reprimand could have been issued on the spot ("No playing tag. Find something else to play, please.")

I'm in total agreement with you.

on May 15, 2007
This is indeed crazy. This falls under the roof of litigation I would guess. I talked to an insurance agent once about all these things going on now that cannot be done for fear of lawsuits...in your case playing tag. He said it's all driven by lawyers not insurance companies. The lawyers are jumping all over these cases knowing that the schools will settle out of court not wanting to bother dragging their school thu the mud and then the insurance companies start putting on the pressure and on and on it goes with new rules and regs being made up almost daily.

It's ridiculous and making a mountain out of a mole hill makes it even more ridiculous.

Tell me......do they even play dodge ball anymore?

on May 15, 2007
Remember the day when cuts, bruises, sprained ankles and even a broken arm or leg was something to show off? How did the kids who played rough and tumble games become the parents afraid to see their kids play?
on May 15, 2007
It's ridiculous. We hear all the time about our country's kids having an obesity problem but then they make the active games against the rules. I guess they should just sit down at recess and play pattycake - oops, no that involves slapping. I guess they could just run laps during recess. It gets a little ridiculous. I'm going to have to ask my boys if they are allowed to play tag at school.
on May 15, 2007
I guess they could just run laps during recess.


You know what is funny to me about that comment? I actually know a kid who was running during a relay and tripped over his big floppy feet and fell teeth first onto the gym floor. We were in the same junior highschool class. I can still see him falling and the upside down smile where his front teeth used to be.

He was just running from one end of the gym to the other! He wasn't an especially bad athlete either. He was just a tall teenage kid with huge feet. We stopped the class (most of us just stopped what we were doing amazed by what happened. Imagine a record being pulled out from the needle and that's how the class stopped.

He went to the hospital and had dental surgery. No one got blamed but I'm sure the PE teacher felt awful. I always wonder if that happened now, if it would be the same attitude.

Maybe I'm over reacting. My dad has coached football for 35 years in highschool. I'm going to ask him about this when I get back to Canada next month. I do remember him saying that the paperwork has increased exponentially.